In the era of Web 2.0 it is hard to stay traditional journalist, who digs for facts, check their authenticity, presents two or more opinions, and keeps neutrality hoping for high ratings and a lot of subscribers. Traditional media are not interactive, except of limited sections for readers’ letters, selected audience participation in talk shows, and censored phone calls to the broadcasting studios.
Listen to this blog as a podcast
Now audience is changing the way they use news outlets – newspapers, magazines, television and radio. More and more people prefer not to wait for paper versions or scheduled broadcast, but use the internet as an immediate and great source of news. Moreover, news customers love to express their opinions on events, discuss them online, as well as share news to each other.
That is why every given year we hear that another magazine or paper stopped quite expensive printing and completely focused on much more cheaper websites, offering hybrid of traditional journalism and new media tools like forums, message boards, blogs, video, podcasts, polls and variety of interactive applications.
Traditional newsrooms will likely stay as the news research laboratories and production plants
Printing and broadcasting, as I think, will not die due to overwhelming web penetration – as theater did not die after inventing cinema and cinema did not disappear after inventing television. Traditional newsrooms will likely stay as the news research laboratories and production plants. Let us use here marketing terminology – unique sustainable competitive advantages (SCAs) of traditional media are to stay news research and production companies. Only the form, style and way of delivering the final products will change due to further integration with online tools, their development and transformation.
As it is known, journalism profession is suffering last decades due to economical troubles, its internal ethical and competency problems, and public pressure. Such negative trend leads to overall shrinking of so-called public, respectful journalism deforming it towards entertainment to win viewers, listeners and readers. From the other side online citizen or “grassroots journalism” where anybody can have an access to the social Web and can become a reporter is occupying abandoned journalistic genres and even sometimes replacing professionals. But again, traditional journalism will not completely die because anybody now is able to takes pictures, record video, and publish them on Facebook, Twitter, YouTube and Flickr. Let us use marketing terminology once more – traditional journalism still has the strong set of SCAs in comparison to the grassroots one.
Anyone now can be a witness of events, share the raw records and pictures online with his comments and thus get his minute of fame
Sure, anyone can occasionally become a witness of events and accidents, share the his raw records and pictures online with his comments and thus get his minute of fame, which is an actual dream of every journalist. But only media profs has skills to differentiate important news from not so important, check the facts to their authenticity, and present the news in context and dynamics. So, I see the major weakness of citizen / grassroots journalism in the social Web. It is in a potential inability to properly answer the most required question from the news formula like “What does this mean to us and our community?”
Having over 12 years of journalism experience on TV, radio and online, I sometimes act as a media expert about social media trends. So, in June 2012 I talked about it in studio of the Ukrainian section of Voice of America with Myroslava Gongadze. I will appreciate your comments to the following video:
- In an Era of ‘Citizen Journalism’, is the Notion of Credibility Becoming Irrelevant? (mareemacritchie.wordpress.com)
- Vocus Releases State of the Media 2013 Report (everything-pr.com)
- Gannett outfits newsroom with iPhones, iPads (reviews.cnet.com)
- Traditional and social-media-based journalism, roles, differences and shortcomings (nextlevelofnews.com)
- Brands Need a New Type of Newsroom (digiday.com)
- College Journalists Need Free Speech More Than Ever (theatlantic.com)